ALEX Home now includes ben admin—one platform for enrollment, admin, and year-round support See More

The Good, the bad, and the ugly: An (honest) post-open enrollment checklist

Open enrollment is officially in the rearview mirror. The selections are made. The spreadsheets are (mostly) closed. The last-minute employee questions have slowed down. And your team might finally have time to tackle that very long list of projects that got pushed aside. (Or maybe just enough time to close out the year and enjoy some of the holidays… let’s be real).

But before you move on, there’s one more thing worth doing: taking a good, honest look at the technology and processes that got you through enrollment.

What worked? What caused unnecessary headaches? Where did employees get stuck? And, perhaps most importantly, what do you really, really not want to repeat next year?

A post-open enrollment audit helps you answer those questions while your memory is still fresh. It’s also an opportunity to look beyond enrollment itself and evaluate whether your benefits technology will be strong enough to support your team and employees throughout the rest of the year.

Let’s get honest and document that OE experience!

4 questions to ask yourself post-open enrollment

Here are four questions to ask yourself, think about, ponder, consider, with a few examples. Then use our actual post-open enrollment checklist (we all love a list!) to create your documentation on OE overall.

1. How much heavy lifting did your team do during implementation?

As you know, a successful open enrollment doesn’t happen by accident. A lot of work happens behind the scenes, from configuring plans and coordinating with carriers to communicating changes and preparing employees to make smart decisions.

Your technology partner should make that work easier, not add another project to your already-full plate.

Think back to when you first implemented your current benefits platforms—and when you kicked things off for this year’s open enrollment. Ask yourself:

  • Did implementation stay on schedule? If not, what caused delays?
  • Were responsibilities and expectations clearly communicated from the beginning?
  • Did your vendors proactively flag potential issues, or did your team have to chase down answers?
  • Was training sufficient to help HR and benefits administrators feel confident using the system?
  • How responsive were your vendors when questions or unexpected issues came up?
  • Did your team spend more time managing the technology than actually supporting employees?

That last question is especially important. Your vendors should take ownership of their part of the process. When something breaks, you shouldn’t be left troubleshooting problems on your own.

Look for a partner that combines reliable technology with genuine, above-and-beyond customer service. That’s the philosophy we lead with here at Jellyvision. And we’re not afraid to say that it makes our hearts happy when we get glowing feedback.

“We have worked with Jellyvision since 2017. They handle anything and everything we send their way, quickly and graciously, even through three different premium rate changes for some of our plans! I cannot think of anything that could improve the experience.”
Jellyvision Customer

Great software is only half of the equation. It’s also about having someone pick up the phone when you need help—and anticipating problems before you even know they’ve arisen.

2. Was choosing and enrolling in benefits actually easy for employees?

Did your employees actually understand the benefits they selected, or did they simply make it through the enrollment process?

It’s not just about crossing the finish line. Employees want to understand their options, make good decisions, and leave confident they have the coverage they need to stay physically, mentally, and financially healthy this year. But that can be surprisingly difficult when information is scattered across multiple platforms, or requires a dictionary to decipher complicated terms.

Think about your open enrollment journey from start to finish:

  • Were plan comparisons clear enough to help employees understand their options?
  • Did employees have access to personalized guidance when making decisions?
  • Could they move from learning about a benefit to actually enrolling in it without switching between disconnected systems?
  • Did employees know when their elections were complete? Did you have to chase down folks who thought they were finished, but hadn’t fully enrolled?
  • Did employees have an easy way to find answers when they needed them? Were there repeated questions, or last-minute requests for help?

It’s also worth looking at the data. How many employees completed enrollment on time? How many needed additional assistance? Were there particular plans or benefits that brought up more questions than others?

Closing out open enrollment isn’t the end of your benefits education responsibilities. It’s the beginning. Your enrollment period sets the tone for how your workforce engages with their benefits year-round, when they’re actually using them.

So if your employees don’t understand what they’re choosing, they may miss opportunities to get more value from their benefits in the moments that truly matter—like when they’re facing a health challenge, or looking for ways to save on medical expenses throughout the year.

3. What happens after open enrollment?

Open enrollment gets a lot of attention, but it’s only one part of the benefits experience.

New hires need to make elections. Employees get married, have children, move, and experience other life changes that affect their coverage. People have questions about deductibles, prescriptions, and what’s covered. And HR is often the first stop when they don’t know where else to turn.

While you’re conducting a post-open enrollment audit, don’t forget to consider the other 11 months of the year, too:

  • Can new hires easily understand and enroll in their benefits?
  • How are qualifying life events handled? Can employees make changes themselves without having to involve your HR team?
  • Do employees know where to go for accurate, personalized benefits guidance outside of open enrollment?
  • Does your system automatically communicate qualifying life events and changes to carriers, or does someone need to export, format, and send files manually?
  • How are midyear exceptions, rehires, and prorated contributions handled?
  • Can employees get answers when HR isn’t available?

You’re likely all too familiar that benefits questions happen outside your 9-to-5. If your benefits technology doesn’t provide reliable, personalized guidance around the clock, you’re leaving your workforce in the dark.

And don’t overlook the administrative side, either. After enrollment closes, is someone on your team rebuilding a master spreadsheet and reformatting carrier files? Are employees’ benefit changes sitting in a weekly batch file when they could be sent sooner?

These aren’t just minor inconveniences. They create extra work and can introduce delays or errors that affect employees’ coverage.

4. What should you document now?

Now it’s time to turn those observations into something useful. And no, we’re not suggesting you spend the next three weeks building a 40-page report.

A post-open enrollment audit doesn’t have to be complicated to be valuable. Even a simple spreadsheet or shared document can help your team capture what worked, what didn’t, and what you’d like to improve before next year. (And remember, this is the time to be honest; it’s okay if you experienced roadblocks, hiccups, had poor employee feedback; those are all data points that we can learn from).

Start with what you already have: enrollment reports, employee surveys, support tickets, platform analytics, and feedback from your team. We’ve included a comprehensive list of data points below, but you don’t need to track every single one. Focus on the metrics and observations that are most relevant to your organization and the challenges you encountered this year.

Your post-open enrollment checklist

Use the categories below to organize your findings. Gather relevant data, feedback, and observations from your team and existing reports to build a clearer picture of what worked, what didn't, and where there's room for improvement.

Implementation and vendor support
Employee experience
Year-round benefits administration
Technology and vendor performance

Turn your findings into a short list of priorities

Once you’ve gathered what you can, look for patterns. Were there recurring issues that created extra work for HR? Common points where employees got stuck? Problems your vendor couldn’t resolve?

Start by identifying two or three priorities, and document what happened, why it matters, and what could be improved.

Example Priority: Make plan comparisons easier

What happened?

Employees repeatedly asked HR how to compare medical plans.

Why it matters?

HR spent time answering the same questions, and employees lacked clear guidance.

What could improve?

Explore better plan comparison tools and employee guidance.

A few notes are plenty. You’ll have a useful starting point for conversations with your team, leadership, or current vendors.

Some issues might be resolved with clearer communication or a process change. Others may point to larger gaps in your technology or vendor support.

You don’t necessarily need a whole new system because one part of enrollment was frustrating. But if the same major problems keep showing up, it’s worth asking whether your current technology can solve them.

A final thought: how can you make next year’s benefits experience better, starting now?

You don’t have to solve every problem before the end of the year.

The value of a post-open enrollment audit is capturing data and feedback while the experience is still fresh. Whether you have a detailed report or a handful of notes, you’ll be better prepared to make improvements, have productive conversations with your brokers/vendors, and advocate for changes when the time comes.

And if your audit reveals bigger issues with your current benefits technology, you don’t have to wait until next year’s enrollment deadline is looming to explore your options.

Because here’s the thing: Your benefits technology should be doing more of the work, not creating more of it.

That’s the thinking behind ALEX Home. By bringing benefits administration, decision support, and year-round guidance together in one connected experience, we help employees get everything their benefits are worth while giving HR valuable time back.

With practical AI built in from the start, employees can get answers grounded in their employer’s actual benefits, not generic information from the internet. And with an API-first approach that connects with existing systems, ALEX Home helps reduce the manual work and disconnected processes that keep HR teams busy.

The goal isn’t to give your team another piece of technology to manage. It’s to make benefits easier for the people who administer them and the people who rely on them.

Open enrollment may be over, but making benefits better doesn’t have to wait until next fall.

Ready to bring your benefits into one connected experience?

Frequently asked questions

HR teams should evaluate four key areas: implementation and vendor support, the employee experience, year-round benefits administration, and overall technology performance. Reviewing enrollment completion rates, employee feedback, administrative workload, and manual workarounds can help identify what worked and what needs improvement.

Look beyond the enrollment interface. Evaluate implementation support, system reliability, integrations with HRIS, payroll, and carriers, employee guidance, year-round functionality, and vendor responsiveness. A strong partner should reduce administrative work, help employees make informed decisions, and take ownership when issues arise.

Consider evaluating other providers when recurring technology problems create unnecessary work, employees struggle to understand or enroll in their benefits, integrations are unreliable, or your current platform can’t support your organization’s changing needs. A pattern of unresolved issues is a good reason to explore alternatives before the next open enrollment cycle.

Document enrollment completion rates, common employee questions, missed deadlines, implementation challenges, vendor response times, system errors, manual workarounds, carrier file delays, and employee feedback. These findings provide a baseline for measuring improvements and evaluating future technology investments.

Jump to section

See why over 1,500 customers use ALEX for a better employee benefits experience.

Hey you, join our community!

Join 22,000+ HR pros who receive monthly employee benefits insights, straight to their inbox.

By submitting your information, you agree to Jellyvision’s Terms of Service and Privacy Policy. 

You're using an unsupported browser.

The Jellyvision website no longer supports Internet Explorer. Please switch to Microsoft Edge or Google Chrome to access the site.